Never say to a new mother "remember
to take some time for yourself." Just don't do it. Stuff a sock in your mouth
if you have to, but keep the words to yourself.
I went to a baby shower recently
where a mother of two gave the new mother a rousing devotional talk. The
well-meaning experienced mother, who should surely have known better, resorted
to this tired and useless theme. Finally, she said, "take time for yourself.
It will make you a better mother and a better wife." (Oh, second only to my
distaste for advice to take time for yourself is my abhorrence of the phrase "put your husband first." Like that's actually possible when you have a
screaming baby in your arms.)
Let's give new mothers a break. First, imagine what they actually hear when we say this vicious little phrase.
Here's what a new mother's life is
like: all of a sudden she has an infant on her hands who absorbs every bit of
her attention and love and care. She is delighted that he has arrived, but he
seems to need something different every two minutes. He cries and she has to
comfort him. Then he blows out a diaper and she has to clean up a mess while he
cries and she feels as though she should be comforting him. She remembers that
she has nothing in the house to cook for dinner and feels as though she should
be grocery shopping instead of cleaning up soiled clothing (or bedding, or
furniture, or...) but first she's going to have to comfort him because she really
should be doing that, too, along with the laundry from yesterday's accidents.
Time gets past her and she realizes it's too late to go shopping and she really
should be cooking or at least coming up with a plan for cooking when there's
nothing in the house but she's feeding the baby right now and at least he's not
crying. And she knows she should have found time this morning to change out of her
nightgown and brush her teeth. And she should be taking
a nap right now because the baby woke up twenty times the night before, but
there's no time. She has a nagging
suspicion that she is dreadfully inadequate and that other people, if they knew,
would make fun of her.
To advise this harried, pathetic
person to "take time for herself" is to confirm her fear that there is
something else she is not doing right, and that she is a bad mother. (To tell
her that she should put her husband first is to tell her that she's a bad
wife.) A very reasonable answer for her to give would be something honest like "I don't need
a blooming bubble bath, I need a week off!"
But most of the new mothers respond instead with a sickly smile and a
gnawing anxiety that their well-wisher knows the real truth about them.
I have three children, and
sometimes people inquire of me "are you managing to take time for yourself,
though?" I think about my day so far. At a very early hour of the morning, the
four-year-old came into my room. "Mommy, I had a nightmare. Can I sleep here?
she says. I'm too tired to care, so I grunt and she lies down. She tosses and
bops me in the face.
So I think: okay, I'm already awake, so I'll get up and
have some time to get ready for the day before they wake up. I've been up three
minutes, and just brushed my teeth when the baby wakes up and wants to nurse. With a last glance at my
morning routine list, which is posted optimistically on the wall, I take care
of that. By the time she's finished, the six-year-old is up and wants
breakfast. The children
play tag-team on Mommy's attention for the rest of the day, broken only by the trips to school, with one need or crisis after another.
Breaking up fist fights, rescuing the baby from her climbing adventures,
picking up dangerous objects that the older ones left on the floor for the
little one to find, and trying to do housework fill up the few remaining gaps in the day.
So when someone asks if I manage to
take time for myself, I imagine what would happen if I locked the bathroom
door while the four-year-old was experimenting with shish kebabs on her older
brother, and the baby was discovering the fascinating contents of my purse.
Let's just say it wouldn't be very stress-relieving for me.
Really, what is the point of saying this depressing little phrase? Let's
break it down to its depressing parts. The first word is TAKE. A mother does not take. She is asked to learn how to give, and give and give and give until she thinks
she has nothing left to give, and then give some more. Taking is a foreign
concept to a mother. A mother would be happy to RECEIVE, but she is in a poor
position to TAKE anything.
Next, SOME TIME. How much is some
time? Ten seconds? That might be possible. But no mother wants ten seconds. She
wants an hour, two hours, or two months. "Some time" also sounds like a vague
date in the future. To a mother's brain, focused on the now of crisis, a vague
date is equivalent to never. How much time, and when, is what she is wondering
when she hears this.
FOR YOURSELF. This is the worst
part. Yourself is not the focus when you are a new mother. Yourself is of no
importance to anyone, except maybe the past self you dimly remember. Infants
don't even really know you exist as a separate being, and young children have a
hard time seeing you as human. FOR YOURSELF is a phrase from another planet,
and it doesn't make sense in your frame of reference. It turns the whole phrase
into gibberish, and makes you chuck it out in exasperation, because you don't
have time to understand a new language right now.
So what could we say that would be
helpful to new mothers? How about: "Surprise! I'm here to take care of the
children while you go take a shower right now." Or, I'm coming over to clean
your kitchen since you probably haven't had time to do it yet." (Or maybe the
bathrooms, if you're a really good friend.) If you really believe she needs
some time for herself, take action to make it happen. Buy her two movie theater
tickets (non-refundable) and offer to babysit while she goes out with her
husband for the evening. Fold her laundry. Take the baby for a walk. Be goofy
and fun with the baby or kids while you’re visiting. Make her take a nap or go
to her room and read a good book instead of entertaining you while she's trying
to take care of the baby AND do the housework.
Talk is cheap, so the rule of thumb
is this: if you aren't willing to do something about it, don't mention it. If you are, though, you will become an angel to someone who really needs one.